Implications of the love and trust tanks model 3: the challenge of fixing relationships, mismatched perspectives and unfair framings

(This post explores implications of a relationship model outlined here: Trust and love tanks, and implications for relationships – Jots and Scribbles Please read that before reading the rest of this post.)

If the relationship mode has switched, fixing things will require far more than simply going back to what you were doing before

This applies in church conflict situations, but here I will focus on marriage. At the point where one spouse (let’s call her the wife for this scenario) has had enough and suggests marriage counselling or a separation, the love and trust tank has already gone low. The other spouse (I’ll call him the husband for this scenario) has most likely been failing to top up the love and trust tank with kindness and love in the way their wife receives it, and has likely been in some way unkind or unreliable for some time. But because the relationship was initially in the love and trust positive mode, the put upon wife overlooked many of the problems, and received the love and reliability that was there as who their husband really was. But the imbalance between the positive love and reliability and the negative unkindness and unreliability went on long enough to tip to the conflict and suspicion zone. By the point the wife is asking for counselling or separation, she may have reached the point of viewing the unkind and unreliable acts as the true person, and the positive acts of love and responsibility as inadequate or just for show.

The unkind/unreliable husband may personally feel blindsided by this. He thought things were ok. But he thought that only because he had been ignoring the warning signals over time, and because he assumed that the grace shown when the “love and trust tank” was full enough would continue even as it drained. (Putting off difficult conversations can be appropriate for short periods, but it is then important for the one who delayed the conversation to bring it back up. Otherwise the choice is “nagging” or issues being left undealt with until a tipping point is reached.)

Sometime, the husband identifies the problem with one particular incident or issue around the time of the separation, and thinks that resolving that one issue will take things back to what they were comfortable with. But having lost trust and confidence of being loved, the hurt wife is now viewing everything through a lens of suspicion. Since there has often been an extended period of the husband failing to top up love/trust and acting in ways that diminish love/trust, what is required is change to be substantially better than they have been at showing love and reliability. And this will usually take more time than initially thought.

The frustrating dynamic is that the husband in this case really does sort several things out and act better than he has for some years, but his experience of his wife is worse than it has been, which is very confusing.

There is hope in these situations. But men in these situations (I can speak more directly to men than women, though this dynamic happens both ways) are often in denial about how unloving and unreliable they have been, and how their actions over time have tipped the whole relationship into one of conflict and suspicion not love and trust. To rebuild trust in this situation takes time. My advice is to find a couple you both trust, and lay out what has happened, and ask for what they think was reasonable/unreasonable, and be willing to be accountable to them.

But there is a caveat because humans are complicated. Sometimes, the problem is actually in the perception of the “hurt spouse”. They might be fixed in a “discount the good, amplify the bad” mindset that is unfair to their spouse. That is another reason to get a couple you both trust to listen and advise.

Mismatched perceptions and expectations of the relationship mode can make conversations frustrating.

Where both sides agree it is a love and trust relationship, things generally work. Where both sides agree it is a two way conflict and suspicion relationship, that is horrible but relatively clear. But because these modes are often not verbalised, there can be mismatched perceptions.

So one person can think the relationship is a love and trust relationship, and the other person thinks it is a conflict and suspicion relationship. This often happens around the tipping point. The person who thinks the difficulties are still in the love and trust relationship enters a conversation expecting the usual grace and working together on the problems but finds instead hostility and (unfair) suspicion. From the other side, the person who is suspicious and in conflict treats the way the other person approaches it (as within a love and trust relationship) as a sign of the person not taking the problems seriously.

Another mismatch occurs when people have a hidden assumption that they are free to treat the other person’s words and actions with suspicion while demanding that the other person treat their words with grace and trust. In some cases, this can extend to demanding that the other person treat them as a friend with love and trust, while that person is being criticised and attacked as an enemy. These mismatches have most power when they are hidden- once voiced it generally becomes apparent that this is not fair or sustainable.

In some relationships, one person tries to “fix” the relationship perspective to make the other person carry unfair responsibility.

In some relationships, unhealthy and even abusively controlling dynamics can come from trying to control how actions are perceived. This is subtle, and usually involve emotional manipulation over time. So one spouse (for this scenario, the wife, though it can happen both ways), the controlling one, insists that the husband must interpret her acts as she intends them not as he feels or perceives them. But his acts are all interpreted through her lens of how it makes her feel, and he is told that is the true meaning. This asymmetry (the wife’s acts are to be interpreted through the lens of her intentions and weaknesses, and the husband’s acts are interpreted through the lens of how she feels about them) leads to the husband being almost the slave of his wife. He is constantly being told how he must fill up her love and trust tank, while not being allowed to speak to his own needs or ways she negatively impacts him. The problem is not communication about intentions and weaknesses, nor how acts are perceived. Mutual communication on these can be very helpful. The problem is the asymmetry in whose perspective can be expressed, which makes the relationship lopsided, and governed by the feelings of one person.

Leave a Reply